Placed based development and regeneration

Setting the agenda

CEEDR has focused on the economies of deprived and disadvantaged places. We have a particular interest in how planning, regeneration, and place-based governance affect local communities and neighbourhoods.

Enterprise activity is largely embedded in particular places. Our research demonstrates the importance of understanding this relationship when seeking to improve the economic, social, and environmental conditions of UK regions, cities, towns, and rural areas.

Driving London's Green Business Transition

The first report examines how small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) are supported to reduce emissions. The second considers changes in the labour market relating to green jobs and skills. These PDF documents do not yet meet accessibility standards. We are working to produce accessible versions and will replace the documents when they are available.

Recent projects

Funder: Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC)

UK research on pregnancy- and maternity-related discrimination at work found that small employers had the lowest awareness of the rights of pregnant employees and new mothers. They were also the least likely to provide flexible working options.[1] 

SMEs account for 99.9% of the UK business population, three-fifths of private-sector employment, and around half of private-sector turnover. Previous research highlighted the extent of pregnancy- and maternity-related discrimination in UK workplaces of different sizes. However, it did not make specific recommendations for improving maternity support in SMEs or examine the experiences of new fathers.

Managing new parenthood in an SME differs from managing it in a large organisation. SMEs are often characterised by limited resources and informal approaches to staff management. They may have no dedicated human resources department or written maternity and paternity policies. SME owners and managers may also be more resistant than managers in large organisations to maternity and paternity protection regulations because of concerns about the time and costs involved.

Purpose

This three-year study addresses a gap in detailed understanding of the transition to parenthood in UK SMEs. It is designed to contribute to practice, policy, and academic understanding of maternity and paternity management in SMEs.

The project also contributes to policy debates about parental leave, flexible working, and support for fathers in the workplace. Although it focuses on the UK, it addresses a wider international evidence gap. SMEs remain under-researched despite employing most working parents worldwide.

Partners and stakeholders

The project involves stakeholders in co-designing context-sensitive, low-cost, and scalable approaches to managing new parenthood in SME workplaces.

The project involves stakeholders in co-designing context-sensitive, low-cost, and scalable approaches to managing new parenthood in SME workplaces.

Practice-based co-investigators are:

  • Working Families
  • The Fatherhood Institute.

Confirmed Advisory Board members include:

  • the International Labour Organization
  • the Equality and Human Rights Commission
  • Maternity Action
  • Acas
  • the Federation of Small Businesses
  • the Medical Women’s Federation
  • SME owners and managers
  • SME employees, including expectant and new mothers and fathers
    policymakers.

Methods

The study uses a mixed-methods design combining quantitative and qualitative research.

Qualitative data will examine experiences relating to:

  • pregnancy
  • maternity, paternity, adoption, and shared parental leave
  • flexible working
  • breastfeeding
  • childcare support.

This work will use a longitudinal and participatory approach. It will be accompanied by an awareness-raising intervention co-designed by SME owners, managers, and employees.

Semi-structured interviews will be conducted with owners, managers, and employees in three phases over one year. Focus groups will also be held with:

  • prospective and expectant parents
  • co-workers, to explore their perceptions and experiences of new parenthood and work
  • parents who have requested flexible working.

Two large-scale cross-sectional surveys will examine the experiences of employees and employers working in SMEs. The surveys will complement the qualitative data and explore:

  • attitudes, intentions, experiences, and social norms relating to pregnancy
  • breastfeeding and childcare support
  • parental leave
  • flexible working for parents
  • the availability and uptake of support among mothers and fathers.

The findings will contribute to academic and policy debates.

Outputs

Planned outputs include:

  • a final report
  • datasets produced through the different research methods
  • an awareness-raising toolkit focused on low-cost solutions for SMEs
  • a video supporting positive interactions between employers and employees
  • factsheets
  • short video documentaries.

Dissemination, engagement, and impact activities will include:

  • a stakeholder engagement event
  • a one-day academic conference
  • presentations at academic conferences
  • publications in peer-reviewed journals.

For more information, please contact project leader Dr Bianca Stumbitz at B.Stumbitz@mdx.ac.uk.

[1] See https://www.equalityhumanrights.com/en/managing-pregnancy-and-maternity-workplace/pregnancy-and-maternity-discrimination-research-findings.

Commissioners: Research England and the British Business Bank
Project lead: SQW

This project examined the support environment that encourages entrepreneurship around universities.

The work included a literature review of the concept of the entrepreneurial university ecosystem and a summary of the principal features likely to be relevant to the London ecosystem. It focused particularly on networking, business support, and finance.

The Middlesex team comprised Robyn Owen and Fergus Lyon from CEEDR, working with Hsing-Fen Lee and Simon Best from MLO.

Read the Literature Review and Technical Note.

Commissioner: Department for Communities and Local Government

The European Regional Development Fund was an instrument of EU Cohesion Policy intended to promote economic, social, and territorial cohesion across the European Union. Cohesion Policy for 2014-2020 was oriented towards the Europe 2020 strategy for smart, sustainable, and inclusive growth.

Before the UK voted to leave the European Union, €3.6 billion was expected to be made available for investment in projects across England through the 2014-2020 programme. Approximately 1,600 projects were expected to support 150,000 enterprises, with an average investment of £1.5 million per project.

The projects focused heavily on three priority areas:

  • improving the competitiveness of SMEs
  • promoting research and innovation
  • supporting the transition to a low-carbon economy.

The scale, focus, and duration of the projects may have changed following the UK’s referendum decision, although investment through the England ERDF programme was still expected to remain substantial.

Purpose

The study scoped the continuing evaluation of England’s 2014–2020 ERDF investments. It set out good practice for the evaluation approach and supported Local Enterprise Partnerships (LEPs) in understanding:

  • the areas on which their evaluations should focus
  • the processes that needed to be established
  • the requirements for successful subsequent evaluation.

CEEDR’s role

CEEDR provided expertise in Counterfactual Impact Evaluation for the national evaluation. It also advised and supported LEPs in developing their approaches to summative evaluation.

The project also helped the client consider arrangements for the England ERDF programme after the UK left the European Union.

Commissioner: London Borough of Barnet
Dates: September 2012 to January 2013

In the absence of detailed research and monitoring of enterprise dynamics in Barnet, CEEDR was commissioned by the London Borough of Barnet to examine the borough’s economy.

The project had three aims:

  1. To improve understanding of Barnet’s business economy and provide an informed basis for strategy development and policy action
  2. To improve understanding of business needs and the extent to which existing business support met those needs
  3. To identify indicators for monitoring the performance of the business economy and the effects of support activities.

The study used a mixed-methods approach, combining analysis of existing sources and quantitative data with original primary data collection and analysis.

Other projects

Commissioner: Joseph Rowntree Foundation

This study examined the current and potential roles of the social economy in supporting inclusive growth that generates more and better jobs in UK cities, particularly for people experiencing or at risk of poverty.

The research was conducted in partnership with researchers at the Open University. It included:

a review of international academic and policy literature
case studies of social economy development in 14 international city regions and 10 UK city regions
roundtable discussions with stakeholders and experts in Cardiff, Glasgow, and Sheffield.

Key findings

The social economy comprises organisations with a core social mission, varying levels of participative and democratic control by members, and a commitment to using financial surpluses or profits primarily to achieve their social objectives. These include:

  • social and community enterprises
  • voluntary and community sector organisations
  • housing associations
  • co-operatives and mutuals
  • informal self-help initiatives
  • social finance and support providers
  • alternative business models.

The social economy accounts for approximately 6.5% of European employment. In Sweden, Belgium, Italy, France, and the Netherlands, it accounts for between 9% and 11.2%. Its contribution to UK employment is lower at 5.6%, with 82% of this employment located in the voluntary and community sector. However, these data are likely to underestimate the social economy’s actual size.

Compared with similar European countries, the UK appears to have a strong voluntary and community sector and a growing social enterprise sector. However, it has fewer organisations using alternative governance models, such as co-operatives and employee-owned businesses.

The research identified three broad areas through which the social economy can promote inclusive growth:

  1. Creating jobs and strengthening skills and employability
  2. Building diversified local economies
  3. Contributing to wider economic and institutional transformation.

Analysis of policy and practice identified areas in which UK cities appear to lag behind some of the international case-study cities. It also identified examples of good practice and opportunities for future development.

Successful social economy development often emerges from an enabling context or social economy ecosystem. This comprises different forms of support and a high level of collaboration among organisations within the social economy and across the public and private sectors.

Read the full report. 

Client: Cross River Partnership
Date: 2001

This project examined and assessed a wide range of business support provision in London for the Cross River Partnership.

Its conclusions and recommendations emphasised the need to do more to encourage and support entrepreneurial activity. The study also made detailed recommendations for improving existing support measures, including support for social enterprises.

Contact CEEDR for more details on this project.

Commissioner: Department for Communities and Local Government
Date: 2006

This research involved managing a programme of evidence reviews addressing key policy issues relating to the economies of deprived neighbourhoods.

The project involved working closely with policy advisers and research managers across several government departments. It also included original mixed-methods primary research in several case-study locations.

The project produced three related reports published by the Department for Communities and Local Government. Together, the reports examined sustainable employment as a route out of poverty and social exclusion:

  • The Dynamics of Local Economies and Deprived Neighbourhoods
  • Worklessness in Deprived Neighbourhoods: A Review of Evidence
  • Informal Economic Activities and Deprived Neighbourhoods.

Contact CEEDR for more details on this project or read the report.

Commissioner: Neighbourhood Renewal Unit for the Office of the Deputy Prime Minister
Fund value: £15 million

Launched in 2002, the Deprived Urban Post Office Fund was administered by the Neighbourhood Renewal Unit. It provided grants of up to £50,000 to sub-post offices in the most deprived areas of England, helping them refurbish and diversify their businesses.

The fund aimed to reduce the risk of closure among sub-post offices that were not included in the Post Office’s rationalisation and closure programme.

Purpose

The evaluation assessed the fund’s effects on:

  • the performance of supported sub-post offices
  • other local businesses
  • local communities.

Methods

The research included:

  • an analysis of applications to the fund
  • a survey of successful and unsuccessful applicants
  • an in-depth study of 12 supported sub-post offices
  • surveys of members of the public, business customers, and non-users
  • a follow-up survey of supported sub-post offices to assess longer-term effects.

Outputs

The research produced:

  • a final report
  • a Good Practice Guide for Post Office Diversification.

Contact CEEDR for more details or read the full report.

Client: Re (Regional Enterprise) Ltd
Dates: December 2013-March 2014

This project developed an economic development strategy for the London Borough of Barnet. It brought together recent research and data to produce the borough’s first three-year economic strategy.

The work had three main elements:

  • an economic assessment of the borough
  • consultation to gather the views of Barnet stakeholders
  • proposals for council action, including options for developing the economic strategy.

The strategy focused on translating current data and evidence into a programme of support for economic growth in the borough.

The final revised report to Re (Regional Enterprise) Ltd can be accessed here: Barnet's Economic Development Strategy

Commissioner: Joseph Rowntree Foundation

This project assessed the current and potential effects of new and emerging regional and sub-regional governance structures on the economic and employment needs of disadvantaged places.

The study identified and evaluated examples of good practice in which coordination between different levels of governance, economic policy, and social policy benefited deprived places and the people who lived and worked in them.

The areas studied had different regional economic governance arrangements and included different types of deprived places, including inner cities, coalfields, and rural areas.

The research covered:

  • North East England
  • the East Midlands
  • London
  • South West England
  • Scotland
  • Wales.

The Joseph Rowntree Foundation published the study in three volumes:

  1. Devolution and Regional Governance: Tackling the Economic Needs of Deprived Areas
  2. Devolved Governance and the Economic Problems of Deprived Areas: The Cases of Scotland, Wales and Four English Regions
  3. Interventions to Tackle the Economic Needs of Deprived Areas: Analysis of Six Policy Case Studies.

Contact CEEDR or visit the Joseph Rowntree Foundation website for more information.

Commissioner: Department for Communities and Local Government
Date: 2008

This research contributed to consultation on implementing the recommendations of the government’s Subnational Review of Economic Development and Regeneration.

The review proposed placing a statutory duty on local authorities to assess their local economies. This project sought to improve understanding of the scale and range of local economic assessments and audits being undertaken by organisations operating at local and sub-regional levels.

The project had two elements:

  1. Compiling a comprehensive list of sub-regional partnerships operating in England and identifying their principal forms of local economic activity
  2. Reviewing the economic development strategies, assessments, and audits being undertaken by different types of local authorities and sub-regional organisations.

Primary and secondary research for the second element covered four English regions:

  • the North East
  • the South West
  • the East Midlands
  • London.

The findings were published by the Department for Communities and Local Government in Review of Economic Assessment and Strategy Activity at the Local and Sub-regional Level.

The report reviewed the types of economic assessment being produced at local and sub-regional levels. It also examined changing sub-regional structures and identified tensions requiring attention in the development of future economic assessments and strategies.

Contact CEEDR for more information.

Client: Government Office for London
Research partner: Centre for Regional Economic and Social Research, Sheffield Hallam University
Date: 1996

This study provided baseline indicators for subsequent evaluations of the Objective 2 programme.

Using the baseline study and a range of secondary data, the economic assessment examined:

  • economic trends and prospects
  • business trends and prospects
  • employment and social issues
  • physical infrastructure.

The study also considered the implications for the 1997-1999 Objective 2 programme.

Contact CEEDR for more information.

Client: Enfield Council
Date: 2000

This study built on the Key Sectors in North London project, focusing specifically on Enfield and the Lee Valley corridor within the borough.

The research was intended to inform Enfield’s Economic Development Plan for 2000-2001.

Contact CEEDR for more information.

Commissioner: Countryside Agency
Date: 2006

This study examined the operation of quasi-markets for health and education services in rural areas and the effects of government proposals to extend choice in public services.

The research examined the behaviour of providers in the public, private, and voluntary sectors. It considered their ability and willingness to provide an appropriate range of services for people in rural areas, including members of disadvantaged groups.

Where meaningful choice was unavailable, the study examined:

  • the additional public investment needed to encourage existing or potential providers to respond
  • alternative policy approaches.

The research team included contributors from the Institute for Public Policy Research and Edmund Waterhouse.

Contact CEEDR for more information.

Commissioner: Economic and Social Research Council
Duration: Three years

This seminar series aimed to advance understanding of the roles of homes and neighbourhoods in business formation and entrepreneurship. It also sought to inform enterprise and housing policy and practice.

By examining how entrepreneurship is embedded in homes and neighbourhoods, the series considered entrepreneurial activity as a local asset requiring greater attention in enterprise, neighbourhood, and housing research and policy. It also explored new perspectives on economic growth.

The series comprised three two-day seminars and three one-day seminars:

  1. Seminar 1: Understanding connections between entrepreneurship, home and neighbourhoods
    23 and 24 January 2014, University of Glasgow, Glasgow
  2. Seminar 2: Home-based businesses in their local settings
    16 September 2014, Middlesex University, London
  3. Seminar 3: Entrepreneurship and homes - regulation, finance and planning
    15 January 2015, Department for Business, Innovation and Skills, London
  4. Seminar 4: Entrepreneurial neighbourhoods
    9 and 10 September 2015, Delft University of Technology, the Netherlands
  5. Seminar 5: Pathways to Inclusive Entrepreneurship and Growth
    22 January 2016, 10.00am-4.00pm, Scottish Government, St Andrew’s House, Edinburgh
  6. Seminar 6: Research agenda and policy implications.

Seminar 5 was organised by Dr Darja Reuschke of the University of St Andrews and Tom Craig of the Scottish Government’s Entrepreneurship Team.

Places for Seminar 5 were limited, and participants were asked to register by emailing Dr Darja Reuschke.

Download the programme here

The seminar series was a joint initiative involving researchers from the Universities of St Andrews, Middlesex, Glasgow, and Delft. The organisers were:

  • Dr Darja Reuschke, University of St Andrews
  • Professor Stephen Syrett, Middlesex University
  • Professor Colin Mason, University of Glasgow
  • Professor Maarten van Ham, Delft University of Technology
  • Professor Duncan Maclennan, University of St Andrews.

 

Commissioner: Wales Institute of Social and Economic Research and Data

Commissioned in 2010, this small-scale exploratory study examined trade union roles and participation in the UK Sector Skills Councils.

Using a survey of union representatives and other trade union stakeholders, the research examined how trade unions engaged organisationally with the councils and influenced skills policy agendas.

The study used a case-study approach focusing on:

  • apprenticeships
  • initiatives to increase women’s participation in vocational training, including the Women and Work Sector Skills Initiative
  • international and European models of good practice
  • the Danish vocational education and training system
  • lessons that could be drawn from Denmark.

The resulting paper examined the potential future directions that trade unions could pursue to negotiate and influence skills policy through the Sector Skills Councils.

Commissioner: British Council
Dates: 2009-2013

This project examined interactions between employers and jobseekers during recruitment and selection.

The research found that interventions by local government, employer groups, and trade unions had achieved limited results. It identified problems on both the supply and demand sides of the local labour market and proposed interventions to address them.

British Council funding supported the development of:

  • development programmes for jobseekers
  • a support programme for employers
  • briefings for trade unions, non-governmental organisations, and policymakers.

Activities included development workshops for unemployed jobseekers in the most disadvantaged areas. The workshops aimed to equip participants with job-search, employability, and entrepreneurial skills, enabling them to align their experience and capabilities more effectively with employers’ requirements.

The workshops began in 2009. Over the following four years, more than 3,000 unemployed people completed them. An independent evaluation found that more than 80% of participants progressed within three months to employment or accredited training, or started their own businesses.

Read the report here.

Commissioner: British Academy
Supporting organisation: Department for International Development
Programme launched: November 2017

Modern slavery describes relationships based on severe exploitation, which is often economic. It encompasses practices including forced or compulsory labour, servitude, forced or servile marriage, the sale or exploitation of children, human trafficking, and debt bondage. These relationships involve control over another person through actual or threatened violence and may be enabled by inadequate human rights protections.

Modern businesses depend on global supply chains connecting consumers with goods and labour. The scale and complexity of these supply chains can make them difficult to govern and can prevent exploitative practices from being identified. These risks can be particularly severe in developing countries with weak regulation, especially at lower levels of supply chains.

Policy context

The United Nations Sustainable Development Agenda called on national governments to take immediate and effective measures to:

  • eradicate forced labour
  • end modern slavery and human trafficking
  • prohibit and eliminate the worst forms of child labour by 2030.

This target, Sustainable Development Goal 8.7, was connected with wider objectives concerning decent work, gender equality, and access to education.

Several countries also introduced domestic legislation. The UK Modern Slavery Act 2015 requires organisations to report on the measures they have taken to prevent slavery and human trafficking within their businesses and supply chains, or to state that they have taken no such measures.

The Act was intended to provide law enforcement agencies with tools to address modern slavery, establish penalties for offences, and improve support and protection for victims.

Business risks and evidence gaps

Businesses require efficient global supply chains but face legal, reputational, and economic risks associated with slavery, human trafficking, and child labour. Productive supply chains also depend on trained, healthy, and educated workers.

Failure to address human rights abuses in production and services can damage businesses’ finances and reputations. Investors and consumers increasingly consider companies’ ethical performance and human rights records.

A central challenge is determining how businesses should respond to actual or potential human rights abuses across complex supply chains. Companies often rely on social audits to identify risks, but these audits may not detect all existing or potential abuses and are seldom open to public scrutiny.

Many human rights violations occur in the informal economy, making them more difficult to identify. Businesses may therefore be unable to determine whether their measures are effective or whether those measures displace harmful practices into less visible parts of the supply chain. Evidence about effective approaches to modern slavery, human trafficking, and child labour remains limited.

Purpose

In response to this evidence gap, the British Academy launched Tackling Slavery, Human Trafficking and Child Labour in Modern Business in November 2017, with support from the Department for International Development.

The programme was intended to support research and make evidence accessible to organisations developing policies, business models, and interventions relating to Sustainable Development Goal 8.7.

It funded eight connected research projects intended to identify promising practice and share evidence about approaches that work at scale in different contexts.

Research teams and locations

Multidisciplinary teams from universities in the UK and USA led the projects. The source identifies participating universities including:

  • the University of Bath
  • the University of Bristol
  • Brown University
  • Coventry University
  • the University of Leeds
  • the University of Liverpool
  • the University of Nottingham
  • the University of Sussex.

Field research took place in:

  • Bangladesh
  • Brazil
  • the Dominican Republic
  • Ghana
  • India
  • Indonesia
  • Jamaica
  • Malaysia
  • Myanmar
  • Nepal
  • Mexico
  • Peru
  • Vietnam.

Research areas

The projects compared production processes across sectors including:

  • chocolate and textiles
  • beef production and timber
  • construction and domestic work.

The programme also included detailed case studies of:

  • smartphone technology development in East Asia
  • child sex trafficking in Jamaica
  • debt bondage and seafood production in Indonesia.

All eight projects examined gender-related issues, including those affecting children. They also worked with researchers and other stakeholders in developing countries to strengthen local capacity to address modern slavery, human trafficking, and child labour.

Read the programme publication in the British Academy Review, No.32, Spring 2018

Commissioner: Cedefop

Dr David Etherington from CEEDR and Professor Carol Costley from the Work and Learning Research Centre conducted this study as part of a wider consortium.

The consortium included:

  • 3s Consulting in Vienna as the lead partner
  • Tallinn University in Estonia
  • Consoltor in Norway.

Findings

The research found that the roles and positions of different participants, and the extent of stakeholder involvement, were the most important criteria for distinguishing between feedback mechanisms. The role of social partners was particularly significant.

The study also identified considerable differences in the involvement of other stakeholder groups, including teachers and students, and among the social partners themselves.

Social dialogue and its influence on cooperation were central to creating close connections between education policy and the labour market. These relationships were also important in responding to challenges associated with the economic downturn.

The economic crisis strengthened social dialogue in vocational education and training in several countries, including France, Spain, and Sweden. In some countries, including Sweden and England, it contributed to new apprenticeship-style systems and feedback mechanisms involving social partners more extensively.

Read the report.

Commissioner: Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy

The government’s National Security Strategy and Strategic Defence and Security Review introduced ‘Promoting our Prosperity’ as a national security objective.

Associated commitments included:

  • refreshing defence industrial policy to support the growth and competitiveness of the UK defence industry
  • encouraging greater innovation in defence procurement
  • ensuring that investment decisions contributed to a more dynamic and productive economy.

The Department for Business, Innovation and Skills identified a need for a stronger understanding of the defence sector’s contribution to the UK economy. It commissioned this project to update and expand the evidence available to the government when assessing the costs and benefits of defence investment decisions.

The project focused particularly on identifying the wage premium associated with skilled jobs in the UK defence sector compared with jobs requiring similar skills in other sectors. The research used an experimental approach, including Propensity Score Matching.

Read the report.

Client: Economic and Social Research Council

In 2010, the Coalition Government introduced a more stringent workfare or ‘work first’ system than that used by previous New Labour governments. Access to benefits became conditional on stricter work and job-search requirements. The reforms also extended the use of the benefit cap and sanctions.

The government established the Work Programme as its principal welfare-to-work programme, expanding the market for services supporting people experiencing long-term unemployment.

Methods and purpose

Drawing on stakeholder interviews and a literature and evidence review, the research:

  1. analysed and assessed the implementation of the Coalition Government’s welfare reforms, focusing on different aspects of welfare and benefit conditionality
  2. assessed the extent to which conditionality reinforced poverty and social exclusion among benefit claimants
  3. considered how welfare reform and increased conditionality affected claimants’ social rights.

Findings

The findings suggested that conditionality played a relatively minor part in improving employment outcomes, particularly for more disadvantaged groups.

The research also identified potential longer-term disadvantages, including poverty, low pay, and continued in-work poverty.

Read the report.

Commissioned by the Economic and Social Research Council

This seminar series aims to advance knowledge on the roles of homes and neighbourhoods in firm formation and entrepreneurship and inform/influence enterprise and housing policy and practice. By gaining a better understanding of the significance of the embeddedness of entrepreneurship in homes and neighbourhoods we seek to critically advance the view that entrepreneurial activities are local assets that require more attention in enterprise, neighbourhood and housing research and policy, and open up new perspectives for economic growth.

This series will comprise three two-day and three one-day seminars over the course of three years:

  • Seminar 1: Understanding connections between entrepreneurship, home and neighbourhoods, 23rd and 24th January 2014, University of Glasgow, Glasgow.
  • Seminar 2: Home-based businesses in their local settings, 16th September 2014, Middlesex University, London.
  • Seminar 3: Entrepreneurship and homes – regulation, finance and planning, 15th January 2015, BIS, London.
  • Seminar 4: Entrepreneurial neighbourhoods, 9th and 10th September 2015, Delft University of Technology, Netherlands.
  • Seminar 5: Pathways to Inclusive Entrepreneurship and Growth, 22nd January 2016, 10 am –4 pm at the Scottish Government, St Andrews House, Edinburgh
    Organisers and contact: Dr Darja Reuschke, University of St Andrews,
    Tom Craig, Entrepreneurship Team, Scottish Government

*Places are limited. For registration, please, send an email to Darja Reuschke.
Download the programme here

  • Seminar 6: Research agenda and policy implications

The seminar series is a joint initiative by researchers from the Universities of St Andrews, Middlesex, Glasgow, and Delft. The organisers comprise: Dr Darja Reuschke (St Andrews); Prof Stephen Syrett (Middlesex); Prof Colin Mason (Glasgow); Prof Maarten van Ham (Delft University of Technology) and Prof Duncan Maclennan (St Andrews).

Commissioned by the Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS)

A growth hub is a local public/private sector partnership led by the Local Enterprise Partnership (LEP). Partners often include chambers of commerce, Federation of Small Businesses and other business bodies, universities/university business schools, private sector bodies, and national government. The growth hubs partnerships are designed to promote, co-ordinate and deliver business support within an LEP, providing a mechanism for integrating national and local business support so it is easier for businesses to access. This simplification aspect is a central purpose of the growth hubs. There is now a complete network of thirty nine growth hubs. The purpose of this project is to provide an initial evaluation of the growth hubs by 1) reviewing the Annual Report and other documents produced by each hub 2) classifying the hubs into five types based on their delivery model, as well as other factors 3) conducting interviews to further clarify and assess the nature of the delivery model and its impact 4) Assessing each growth hub’s progress in terms of simplifying business support.

Impact on local economic growth and governance

The objective of transforming the prospects of disadvantaged areas and promoting local economic growth has been a recurrent policy concern of successive governments. At CEEDR we have worked with all levels of government to help address the problem.

Policy development

We have helped to inform policy development in the area of local economic growth, working closely with the Department of Communities and Local Government (DCLG, formerly ODPM);other Government departments (including Business Innovation and Skills, Work and Pensionsand HM Treasury); and many local authorities and sub-national. Our work includes:

  • original empirical research;
  • reviews of the existing evidence base; and
  • evaluation of existing policies.

Our research findings have been influential for over a decade. Notable examples include:

  • Heseltine Review: Professor Stephen Syrett was an invited speaker to the Lord Heseltine Review on UK Competitiveness, in relation to the role of local areas in promoting economic growth (12 July 2012).
  • Advice to DCLG: Professor Stephen Syrett was appointed as a Member of Department of Communities and Local Government Expert Panel on 'Neighbourhoods, Cities and Regions Analysis' (NCRA) (2007-2010) and an invited expert in the DCLG Enquiry Week (March 2012) and other policy review events. Our work was also cited in the major restatement of the regeneration policy agenda by DCLG entitled Transforming places: Changing Lives. A Framework for Regeneration (2008).
  • Participation in the Review of Sub-National Economic Development and Regeneration (SNR) (2006-07), a major cross-governmental review led by HM Treasury. CEEDR submitted a written paper (November 2006)and our work is cited in the Review (2007). Professors North and Syrett were invited experts at successive HM Treasury workshops (July and October 2006).

Enterprise and work in the regeneration of deprived neighbourhoods

We have conducted a number of major reviews of the existing evidence about enterprise and work in regenerating deprived areas for the ODPM/DCLG, as well as undertaking original primary analysis for the Joseph Rowntree Foundation and DCLG.

The impact of our work includes:

  • Local Enterprise Growth Initiative: Our research findings on the weak business base and entrepreneurial culture of deprived areas were taken forward in the design and introduction of a major government initiative in 2005 (£100m per year).
  • Production of think-pieces for DCLG and DWP: Professor Stephen Syrettwas commissioned to produce a think-piece on 'Tackling worklessness in deprived places', presented to a DWP/CLG seminar, and another on 'How the regeneration problem should be addressed', presented to a CLG 'Regeneration Futures' roundtable (August 2009).
  • Guidance related to Post Office closures in deprived areas: CEEDR research led to the publication of a widely circulated and cited good practice guide for Post Office diversification (2005).
  • Evidence presented to Scottish Parliament: Professors David North and Stephen Syrett were invited to present evidence to the Finance Committee of the Scottish Parliament as part of their cross-cutting review of expenditure on area based deprivation.

Governance and processes

Our research work has examined governance practices and processes related to local economic policy, and provided data for understanding the workings of local economies. Impacts include:

  • London Borough of Barnet's economic development strategy: We have an ongoing involvement in the development of this strategy (2012-13).
  • Advising the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills (BIS): In 2012, we were invited to provide BIS with economic and business intelligence for London on an ongoing basis.
  • Local Area Agreements and local economic development: Our research report published by DCLG was launched by the Rt Hon Rosie Winter, Minister of State in July 2009, and fed into wider consultations for the Local Democracy, Economic Development and Construction Act (2009).
  • Local Economic Assessments: Findings from our research on Local Economic Assessments (LEAs) (2008) was a key background document circulated to stakeholders as part of the consultation process over what statutory requirement should be placed upon local authorities to produce LEAs.

Economic Indicators for the North Wales Economy (1998)

For CELTEC - North Wales TEC

CEEDR and the Centre for Applied Research in Economics (CARE) at Middlesex University Business School developed a set of economic indicators to enable CELTEC to monitor trends in the local economy and produce medium term forecasts. The results have been incorporated into a quarterly review of the economy published by CELTEC.

Contact CEEDR for more details on this project.

Local Area Agreements and Local Economic Development

Commissioned by the Department of Communities and Local Government

This research commissioned in 2008, investigated the adoption of economic related indicators within Local Area Agreements and their relation to local processes of economic development. The research provided CLG with a better understanding of the factors that influenced the selection of LAA economic related indicators within particular local areas and the nature of the relationship between these indicators and the particularities of local economies and processes of local economic development. The project involved an in depth investigation of 10 case study areas from across England purposively selected to cover a range of different economic conditions, governance arrangements and types of economic related indicators selected. Within each case study area, primary data was assembled through face-to-face interviews conducted with key stakeholders involved in the LAA process. CLG has used the findings of this work both in relation to the implementation of the recommendations of the Sub National Review on Economic Development and Regeneration and in reviewing the overall LAA process.

Contact CEEDR for more details on this project.

Mapping Partnerships in North London (2000)

for North London TEC

This project for North London TEC Learning and Skills Council (LSC) transition committee involved mapping current economic regeneration partnerships located in the four London boroughs of Haringey, Enfield, Barnet and Waltham Forest that will be contained within the proposed new North London LSC. The study found nearly fifty partnerships and details contact names, key partner organisations, activities undertaken, and funding stream data.

Contact CEEDR for more details on this project.

Commissioned by the Small Business Service (now the Department for Business Innovation and Skills)

This project commissioned in 2002, developed a set of methodologies to measure the impact of different forms of enterprise (social and conventional) on local economies in disadvantaged rural and urban areas. The qualitative and quantitative impacts measured by the tools include: jobs created, services provided, money circulating in the local economy, building 'social capital', and building experience and skills. The results can be used to identify which types of enterprise have a larger impact on disadvantaged areas and to provide evidence of impact of public sector intervention.

Contact CEEDR for more details on this project.

Key Sectors in North London (1999)

For North London TEC

The purpose of this study was to help identify the key sectors to support in North London over the next ten years and to advise on the further research necessary to enable a full assessment of the support needs of each of these sectors. After an overview of sectoral performance for the 1991-97 period, various alternative ways of defining sectors were considered including the notion of 'economic clusters'. Various criteria for identifying key sectors were considered and then 7 key sectors identified and examined in greater depth.

Contact CEEDR for more details on this project.

Taking North London Forward: A Preliminary Study, (1997)

For North London TEC

This study was concerned with providing an overview of recent trends and an analysis of current strengths and weaknesses of the North London economy, using a wide range of existing studies and data sources. It included analysis of trends and prospects in key sectors and different types of business, labour market trends and training provision, demographic and social trends, and physical development and transport.

Contact CEEDR for more details on this project.

Commissioned by the Office of the Deputy Prime Minister/Small Business Service, H.M. Treasury

With the growing interest in the role of businesses in regeneration, CEEDR carried out a review of the evidence relating to business-led regeneration in deprived areas. The study, commissioned in 2002, examined the impact of conventional and social enterprises on deprived areas and examined the evidence relating to different types of policies which have had an influence on business development in deprived areas. Lessons were identified on effective ways to encourage and stimulate business development in regeneration programmes and gaps in the knowledge base examined.

Contact CEEDR for more information.

Regional Intelligence for London


Commissioned by National Institute of Economic and Social Research and the Department for Business Innovation and Skills

This project which was started in 2012 involves the production of monthly reports on factors that may have a major influence on the London economy and its various sub-regions to help understand trends in business and economic output, employment and investment. The work is therefore concerned with capturing 'softer' intelligence and information on current developments to complement existing business and economic data sources.

Contact CEEDR for more information.

Review of North London Strategies and Key Development Projects (1998)

For North London TEC

Following on from the North London Regional Dynamism Conference, CEEDR undertook a detailed review of the strategies and economic development projects being undertaken by the leading partners in economic development within North London, with a view to identifying areas of common interest and issues that need to be addressed.

Contact CEEDR for more information.

Business in a Rural Region: A Rural Proofing Study, (2004)

Commissioned by The Countryside Agency

This research provides information that will contribute to the strategy of the Countryside Agency and other government bodies and departments, to encourage and develop successful rural economies and communities. Specifically, it will inform government and other bodies as to the contribution and impact of businesses located in rural areas, as well as providing specific insights into the mechanisms and linkages of business with local economies and communities in the Southwest region. The research is based on the results of a telephone survey of 84 medium- and large size companies based in rural locations in the South West of England, plus 25 in-depth, face to face interviews with senior managers of a selection of these companies.

Contact CEEDR for more details on this project.

Evaluation of Scotland's Fund to Develop Post Offices in Deprived Urban Areas

Commissioned by Communities Scotland

Having evaluated the Deprived Urban Post Office Fund in England (for the ODPM), in 2006, CEEDR commissioned  to evaluate the Scottish equivalent which had been in operation from 2003 until 2005. The £2 million Fund provided capital grants of up to £50,000 to sub-post offices to assist the retail side of the business and to help retain the socially important services that they can offer deprived communities and vulnerable groups such as the elderly. The research involved an interview survey of all successful applicants, a sample of unsuccessful applicants, and interviews with a number of stakeholder organisations.

Contact CEEDR for more details on this project.

The Use of SRB funding in London, 1994-2000, (2002)

For Learning and Skills Council, North London

This project was concerned with analysing the changing pattern and structure of SRBCF spending in London over all six SRB rounds. By means of comparing the mapping of SRB funding across six London boroughs with that of the governments deprivation measures, the paper aims to assess the extent to which the funds in different rounds have been directed at the most deprived Boroughs.

Contact CEEDR for more details on this project.

Commissioned by The Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy

The Government’s National Security Strategy (NSS) and Strategic Defence and Security Review (SDSR), introduced ‘Promoting our Prosperity’ as a national security objective. This included commitments to refresh defence industrial policy as one of a number of measures to help the UK’s defence industry grow and compete successfully, to drive greater innovation in defence procurement, and to ensure that future investment decisions contribute to a more dynamic and productive economy. To support this work BIS identified a need to better understand the contribution that the defence sector currently makes to the UK economy and commissioned this project to refresh, and develop further, the evidence base to support the UK government in assessing the costs and benefits of investment decisions in defence. A particular focus of the project was on identifying the wage premium associated with skilled jobs in the UK defence sector in comparison with jobs requiring the same skills in other sectors. For this purpose an experimental approach (e.g. Propensity Score Matching) was employed.

Download report